Quick or slow: how does your pension provider compare?

How is your pension provider doing?

“Time is money”, Benjamin Franklin once said. And when it comes to sorting out your pension, he’s certainly not wrong.

Here at Portafina, as soon as you ask us to look into your pension, the clock is ticking and we will request the information we need from your provider to analyse your scheme straight away.

Getting basic information from your pension provider should be easy as pie, right? Unfortunately, it doesn’t always work out that way.

Many things are slowing pension providers down, including a massive increase in requests from people wanting to know their options following the introduction of the pension freedoms in 2015. And yet, these delays could effectively be costing people money. Especially if it means they spend longer in a high-charging, poorly performing scheme.

You may have already experienced this kind of frustration. And please believe us when we say, we know how you feel! We chase dozens of pension providers every day, for information that should be relatively simple to share.

And while we want to give our clients the answers they are looking for as quickly as possible, we also want to set realistic expectations. That’s why we have done a little digging into which pension providers respond the quickest and which take the longest to supply essential details.

Our research for 2017 covers 12,337 requests for information made by Portafina on behalf of 6,821 new clients to over 650 different defined contribution, defined benefit pension scheme providers and scheme administrators.

So, which provider tops our third annual league table and which falls short? And more importantly, does yours feature and where?

Simply the best…or the worst?

Defined Contribution Schemes: a pension scheme where contributions are invested and the size of the pot depends on the performance of investments.


Fastest DC schemes based on average number of weeks to provide information

Canada Life       1.2 weeks   (8th fastest in 2016)
B&CE Benefit  1.6 weeks (10th fastest in 2016)
Hargraves Lansdown  1.8 weeks (6th fastest in 2016)
DHL Group Retirement Plan  1.8 weeks (7th fastest in 2016)
Legal & General Assurance Society  2.0 weeks (New entry)


Slowest DC Schemes based on average number of weeks to provide information

Equitable Life Assurance Society 5.5 weeks   
Mercer Ltd 5.4 weeks  
Fidelity Pension Management       4.4 weeks  
Fidelity Investments 4.4 weeks  
Capita 4.2 weeks (4th slowest in 2016)


Defined Benefit (Final Salary) Schemes: a pension scheme where the amount of pension income you receive in retirement is based on how many years you’ve worked for your employer and the salary you’ve earned.


Fastest DB Schemes based on average number of weeks to provide information

Diageo Pensions  1.6 weeks  (2nd fastest in 2016)
Clerical Medical  2.1 weeks  
Prudential        2.4 weeks  
Phoenix Life Ltd 2.6 weeks  
DHL Group Retirement Plan   2.6 weeks  


Slowest DB Schemes based on average number of weeks to provide information

East Riding of Yorkshire (Council) 17.1 weeks  (Also slowest in 2015)  
Lancashire Council    11.1 weeks  
West Midlands Pension (Council) 10.3 weeks  
Royal Mail Pension 10.2 weeks  
Strathclyde Pension     7.3 weeks (4th slowest in 2016)


And the winners are…

Drum roll please!

And it’s Canada Life topping the poll as the quickest provider, taking on average 1.2 weeks to provide the information necessary to advise clients on their pension.

Coming first place in the performance league for final salary schemes and going one better than their second-place performance the previous year, is Diageo, with an average time of 1.6 weeks.

DHL Group Retirement Plan has shown an impressive performance with a top 5 standing in both our defined contribution and defined benefits lists, outshining most of the specialist pension providers and scheme administrators.

Improvement is needed…

Whilst the top performing companies have coped very well with the additional demand brought by the pension freedoms, the gap to the worst performers has grown considerably.

In fact, the slowest provider, East Riding of Yorkshire, is taking an average of 17.1 weeks to provide the same level of information that Diageo provide in under two weeks. Looking at the bottom five performers overall, Royal Mail Pension scheme is the only non-council scheme to appear.

Generally, across both defined benefit and defined contribution schemes, the slowest providers are taking 1-2 weeks longer on average to provide information in 2017, then they did in 2016.

Jamie Smith-Thompson, Managing Director of Portafina, said, “In this day and age it is pretty shocking to still be measuring these results – and congratulating the best performers – in terms of weeks taken to provide what is generally pretty straightforward information. I look forward to the day when these league tables are measured in seconds!”

Better sooner rather than later…

Your pension could be the difference between just getting by and a future packed with opportunities. Which is why it makes sense to check it on a regular basis. The sooner, the better! Best of all, it shouldn’t cost you a penny to get expert, regulated advice.

For example, here at Portafina, we would review your pension free of charge. A fee would only be due if you liked our recommendation and asked us to act on it. Although, you can walk away at any point with nothing to pay.

Claim your free pension information pack today and discover how Portafina can help you.

What you will get from the pack:Pension Information Guide

  • Get a deeper understanding of what your available options might be
  • Insight into how our no obligation review works and how it could benefit you
  • Details of how to get your review started


Request a free pack

Scottish income taxpayers: what you need to know

What the 2018/19 proposals could mean for you...


Discover more

Skiing tracks

What does a no obligation review mean

Quick and easy guide to no obligation reviews


Discover more

Quick and easy guide to no obligation reviews

Watch our quick video on how a pension review works


Watch now

Add new comment

Call 0800 304 7288 for a friendly chat about your pension

Important Information

We are really looking forward to reading your comments. Before you start writing, please just remember that everything you write will be displayed publically – including your name. Not sure what sort of thing you can write, and what sort of things you should avoid? Please have a quick read of our social rules for guidance.

The details provided in this article are for general information only and are in no way deemed to be financial advice. All of the material is correct as of the publication date, but could be out-of-date by the time you read the article. For our latest information and news, please see our articles section here.

Back to top